Discovery is a process for obtaining information from the opposing side in a lawsuit before a case goes to trial. Each jurisdiction generally follows rules of civil procedure, or the equivalent, which controls this process. The rules allow each side in a case to use various methods such as depositions or interrogatories to force a witness or an opposing party to provide relevant information. It is critical to understand the rules to avoid penalties or other procedural issues. Courts may impose penalties for abusing discovery methods or for refusing to provide information.
The purpose of discovery is to learn what information and evidence the opposing side has concerning a lawsuit. This allows a party to prepare for a trial and avoid surprise in court. A party to a lawsuit, i.e., the plaintiff or defendant, is not restricted to obtaining only evidence that another party is going to use in court. Instead, the rules allow a party to get information that may lead to evidence. This information may include documents, physical objects, expert opinions, or information inside a person’s mind such as the observations of a witness.
The rules of civil procedure or similar rules in a particular jurisdiction control how a case flows through the court system. Such rules also control the process of discovery such as timing, methods, restrictions, and penalties for abusing or failing to comply with discovery. Not knowing the rules may result in serious legal consequences. For instance, a party may fail to raise objections to certain information demands within a certain deadline; such objections might allow the party to avoid making disclosures. Failing to object within the required time may result in the party forfeiting the right to object to producing that evidence later, during the trial.
There are various discovery methods such as depositions or interrogatories. A deposition is process that allows a party to question another party, a witness, or an expert under oath about a lawsuit outside of court. A lawyer usually conducts the deposition for the client, and the person answering the questions must respond truthfully. Interrogatories are a set of written questions concerning the case that a party, witness, or expert must answer truthfully. Both methods can be effective. Depositions, however, are more costly because of the lawyer’s time to prepare and conduct the process.
Lawyers may use some or all of the discovery methods available depending on the case. The court may punish a lawyer or a party for abusing the process. For example, a lawyer may not use discovery to harass another party. A party may also face punishment for refusing to answer questions or provide documents. A court may impose fines, force a party to pay another party’s legal costs, prevent a party from using evidence in court, or even throw someone in jail in extreme situations.
